Australian Food Sovereignty Alliance

Fair food for all Australians

  • About
    • History
      • Origins of AFSA by Russ Grayson
    • Our Team
      • Current National Committee
      • Past committees
    • Governance
    • President’s report
    • International
    • Press
      • In the News
      • Media Releases
    • Get in touch
  • Farmers
    • Farming on Other People’s Land
    • Community Supported Agriculture
    • Workers’ Rights
  • Legal Defence Fund
    • Our Services
    • Who we support
    • Past efforts
    • Campaigns
    • Our Vision
  • Peoples’ Food Plan
  • CSA
  • Events
    • Fair Food Week
    • Food Sovereignty Convergence 15-24 Oct 2020
      • Watch: Food Sovereignty Convergence 2020
    • AFSA Solidarity Economy Sessions
      • Why solidarity economies?
      • What is a solidarity economy?
  • Submissions
  • Join Us
    • Join Us
    • AFSA Members’ Sesssions
  • Buy the Book!
    • Farming Democracy
    • Cart

STOP the sale of GM Golden Rice in Australia

February 8, 2018 by Courtney Young

Recently, Food Standards of Australia and New Zealand (FSANZ) approved an application (A1138) to permit products containing GM golden rice to be sold in Australia and New Zealand.

We are asking Ministers on the Ministerial Forum of Food Regulation to call for a review of the approval in order to safeguard community health and food sovereignty in Australia and globally. Head over to the campaign page here to add your name to the letter.

What is GM Golden Rice?

Golden rice is a genetically engineered line of rice that produces pro-vitamin A (beta-carotene). It was developed by International Rice Research Institute (IRRI) as a technocratic, quick fix for vitamin A deficiency (VAD) occurring in some countries of the ‘global south’.

What’s the big deal?

1.   Golden rice is not as effective as a healthy, varied diet and has less Vitamin A than other food sources such as carrots.

Vitamin A deficiency, and malnutrition in general, cannot be addressed through golden rice or other forms of genetic engineering. It is a socio-economic issue that requires structural changes to improve standards of living and ensure people have access to a diverse range of healthy, nutritious and culturally appropriate foods. Further, a single carrot contains more vitamin A than nearly 4kg of cooked GM golden rice. Vitamin A degrades in storage, which means a person would need to eat 31 kg of golden rice within 75 days after harvest to get the same amount as in a handful of fresh parsley.

2.   FSANZ approval will lead to the production of GM Golden Rice in the Philippines, thereby undermining local food sovereignty and democracy.

By permitting golden rice to be sold, FSANZ is thereby supporting the global GM regime that undermines regional food sovereignty. Filipino farmer-led group, MASIPAG have spoken out about how Australia’s decision will mean the Philippines will automatically approve the production of GM rice without democratic participation. They note that there are no studies comparing this rice with locally available Vitamin A rich food or with the government programme of supplements. GM golden rice is set to benefit major corporations, like Syngenta, rather than farmers and communities. Filipino farmers, along with farmers in India and Bangladesh, could be seduced into growing GM golden rice under unfair contracts, rejecting traditional varieties that are nutritionally diverse and suitable for the environment.

3.  Products containing GM golden rice will not be labelled appropriately

GM golden rice will not be directly imported into Australia but it has been approved so that a recall is not required if it is found in imported rice. Its status as a contaminant means GM golden rice will also not require labelling. The Australian consumer will be unaware of how much GM golden rice is in their food and what that means for the food’s nutritional properties. We ask for thorough labelling and complete transparency so that consumers are fully informed.

4.   FSANZ have not adequately assessed the safety of GM golden rice.

The application to permit the sale of golden rice in Australia has been assessed using unpublished applicant data. FSANZ did not receive, or request, any ingestion/feeding studies with the application, so there are no publications on whether GM rice would cause allergic reactions or even anaphylaxis in children, immune compromised people or the elderly. The Golden Rice crop is unstable, as is shown by the wildly varying b-carotene yields. FSANZ cannot do an adequate assessment on nutritional safety due to this instability, especially in the levels of nutrients and anti-nutrients.

What do we want?

Genetic modification is a powerful technology with potential detriments not yet fully understood, and it should not be permitted in our food system. GM foods are wholly inappropriate given we already have more than enough food to ‘feed the world’ and the means to produce healthy food, utilizing regenerative, agroecological practices.

We are asking the Ministers on the Ministerial Forum of Food Regulation to review the FSANZ approval of GM golden rice (A1138) under section 21 of the FSANZ Act. We ask for comprehensive 90 day feeding trials, peer-reviewed evidence that the GM golden rice can be stored and cooked without nutrient loss, and data demonstrating that the GM golden rice produces a stable level of Vitamin A. We also demand complete transparency and process based labelling so that all products containing potential traces of GM Golden Rice, including highly processed foods like rice bran oil, are labelled clearly.

Head over to the campaign page here to add your name to the letter.

Filed Under: GMO

Support Food Sovereignty

Join or renew your AFSA membership today!

Search

Recent Posts

  • Can agriculture stop COVID-21, -22, and -23? Yes, but not by greenwashing agribusiness
  • 2020 National Committee Report
  • Nominations to the AFSA National Committee for 2020-2021
  • Food Sovereignty Convergence 2020 Schedule
  • AFSA’s Response to the ACCC’s Perishable Agricultural Goods Inquiry

Read more about…

Latest submissions

FSANZ proposes ‘licence to sell lettuce’ – AFSA says NO

On 3 May 2019, Food Standards Australia New Zealand (FSANZ) released an information paper on its proposed approach to a review of food safety standards in the Food Standards Code (the Review). The intention is to create a consistent and up-to-date approach to food safety management with regard to so-called “high-risk horticulture,” which includes a […]

NSW Fresh Food Pricing Parliamentary Inquiry Hearing

On Friday 22 June 2018, AFSA attended the NSW Fresh Food Pricing Parliamentary Inquiry Hearing at Parliament House in Sydney. AFSA was selected and recognised as a key stakeholder in the food system by the parliamentary members in this Upper House inquiry. Tammi Jonas, president of AFSA, and our paralegal Sarah de Wit were welcomed […]

Response to the Proposed Draft Australian Animal Welfare Standards and Guidelines for Poultry

View AFSA’s entire submission here.  The current review of the Model Code of Practice for the Welfare of Animals – Domestic Poultry offers the first opportunity in 15 years to improve the minimum welfare standards for domestic poultry in Australia. It provides the chance to modify Australian standards to reflect current animal welfare science and […]

Poultry Welfare Reforms Fact Sheet

The Codes for animal welfare for poultry are being reviewed for the first time in over 15 years. The result will be one Australia-wide Code on animal welfare for poultry. Two main documents, along with an independent Farmed Bird Science Welfare Review and many supporting papers, have been released for public comment: The Draft Standards […]

Collective action in support of small-scale, regenerative farmers

In support of small-scale, regenerative farmers in Victoria, the following organisations have submitted responses to the Victorian Government’s Planning for Sustainable Animal Industries Draft Planning Provisions. Australian Food Sovereignty Alliance Victorian Farmers Market Association Melbourne Farmers Market Association Regenerative​ ​Agriculture​ ​Industry​ ​Group​ City of Whittlesea

Newsletter

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Become a member

Join or renew

Already a member?

Login

Update membership details

Recent posts

  • Can agriculture stop COVID-21, -22, and -23? Yes, but not by greenwashing agribusiness December 15, 2020
  • 2020 National Committee Report November 3, 2020
  • Nominations to the AFSA National Committee for 2020-2021 October 23, 2020
  • Food Sovereignty Convergence 2020 Schedule October 15, 2020
  • AFSA’s Response to the ACCC’s Perishable Agricultural Goods Inquiry October 13, 2020

Copyright © 2021 · Outreach Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in